Model explanation methods answer different questions: screening describes marginal association, model-based importance reflects fitted structure, permutation measures performance sensitivity, RFE evaluates subsets, and local explanations attribute one prediction. None automatically implies causality.
MechanismFollow a feature from raw association through fitted-model importance to a local prediction contribution and note where the meaning changes.Failure modeTreating importance/attribution as a causal effect or ignoring correlated features that can share/displace importance.VerificationPerturb one feature or repeat importance on held-out/resampled data and check whether the claimed explanation is stable and prediction-linked.
Experiment deliberately
Choose one feature, compare its screening score, global importance and local effect, then explain why the three numbers need not rank it identically.
Importance is not one number. Statistical significance, univariate AUC, model reliance, subset selection and local effects answer different questions. Compare them before deciding that a feature “matters”.
Feature-importance calculation process
From evidence to selected features
Use training/validation evidence for screening and selection; reserve held-out evidence for final model assessment.